A trustee is not automatically responsible when a trust investment loses value. In Massachusetts, the question is whether the trustee made and monitored investment decisions prudently, based on what they knew at the time. A market downturn can hurt a carefully managed trust. A loss caused by an unreasonable decision may give beneficiaries grounds to act.
If you are a beneficiary, you may want to know where the money went. If you are the trustee, you may worry that every loss will be blamed on you. Understanding the trustee’s duties can help both sides assess what happened.
What Investment Duties Does a Massachusetts Trustee Have?
Under Massachusetts’ prudent investor rule, a trustee must invest and manage assets with the trust’s purposes and terms in mind. The trustee should consider the needs of the beneficiaries, the amount of risk involved, and how each investment fits within the trust’s overall portfolio. The law generally calls for reasonable diversification, though circumstances can justify a different approach.
For example, a trust that needs to make regular payments may call for a different investment approach than one intended to hold assets for decades. The trustee must also act in the beneficiaries’ interests, rather than use trust assets for personal gain.
When Can Investment Losses Point to a Breach of Duty?
Poor returns alone do not establish that a trustee breached a duty. Massachusetts law evaluates investment decisions in light of the circumstances when the trustee acted, rather than judging them solely by the outcome. It also considers an individual investment as part of the overall portfolio.
A closer review may be warranted if a trustee:
- Put most of the trust’s money into one risky investment without a sound reason
- Kept unsuitable assets without reviewing whether they still served the trust
- Ignored investment directions in the trust document
- Chose an investment because it benefited the trustee personally
Context matters. Holding a concentrated asset may be reasonable for one trust and imprudent for another. The trust’s instructions, the beneficiaries’ needs, and the trustee’s reasons for acting all deserve review before anyone draws a conclusion.
What Can a Beneficiary Do if Trust Investments Raise Concerns?
Start by asking for information. An accounting can help you see what the trust owned, how its assets changed, and what the trustee spent or distributed. Massachusetts law requires trustees to provide accounts to certain beneficiaries at least annually and to other qualified beneficiaries who request them, subject to the law’s terms.
You can ask for information beyond the annual account. A trustee must keep qualified beneficiaries reasonably informed about the trust’s administration and respond promptly to their requests for related information, unless doing so would be unreasonable under the circumstances.
Once you have the records, ask the trustee about any decision that concerns you. There may be an explanation that is not apparent from an account statement. If your concerns remain, a trust administration attorney can review the trust document and records with you.
If a trustee has breached a duty, a court can order appropriate relief. Depending on the circumstances, that may include requiring an accounting, ordering the trustee to restore a loss, or removing the trustee. Poor performance alone does not establish a claim or determine the remedy.
How Can Trustees Manage Investment Risk and Their Responsibilities?
If you serve as trustee, begin with the trust document and the beneficiaries’ needs. Review the assets you received, develop a reasoned investment approach, and revisit it as circumstances change. Keep records of the information you considered and why you made significant decisions. Massachusetts law calls for a trustee to review trust assets within a reasonable time after accepting the role or receiving them.
You can seek financial advice when you need it, while continuing to oversee the trust and the work done on its behalf. If a proposed investment or an existing loss raises legal questions, ask for guidance before the problem grows.
Get Clarity on a Trust Investment Loss
An investment loss can be upsetting, but the account balance is only part of the story. At Surprenant, Beneski & Nunes, P.C., we help Massachusetts trustees understand their administration duties and help beneficiaries examine concerns about how a trust has been managed. Contact us to discuss the decisions, records, and next steps involved in your trust.

